1879-1908 – Rev. Jes. Stuart, D.D. (6)
1908-1910 – Rev. N.D. Keith, M.A, D.D. (7)
1911-1920 – Rev. K.W. Barton, B.A. (8)
1920-1925 – Rev. M.N. Omond, M.A. (9)
1925-1927 – Rev. George McGregor, B.D.
1927-1937 – Rev. John Taylor, Ph.D.
1938-1948 – Rev. M.W. Hislip
1948-1949 – Rev. George Bingham
1949-1953 – Rev. B.S. Black
1954-1963 – Rev. Alexander Morrison, B.A., B.D.
1964-1974 – Rev. David Mawhinney, B.Th.
1975-1996 – Rev. Nicholas Vandermey, B.A., B.D.
1996-2018 – Rev. C. Ian MacLean, C.D., B.A., B.Th., M.A.
2019- present – Rev. David Hooper, B.A., B.Ed., M.Div.